Underclassic

Have a lead? Contact us!

Explainer

BAAJA Senate permitting bill: every data center would pay its full grid costs

The Senate advanced a bipartisan permitting package on November 9. A substitute amendment drops the 20-megawatt threshold that limited an earlier version of the bill's grid-cost rules. A final vote has not been held.

November 12, 2026  ·  Underclassic

Updated November 18, 2026. As of Nov. 17 reports, the Senate had not held a final passage vote.

The short answer

Updated Nov. 18, 2026. Details and sources below; the Nov. 16 vote is from the cited report, not yet checked against the Senate roll call.

On November 9, the Senate voted 73 to 25 to invoke cloture on the motion to proceed to H.R. 2347, a House-passed tax bill being used as the vehicle for a much larger package: the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, or BAAJA. The roll call is recorded as vote 257 of the 119th Congress, second session. Two senators did not vote. The next day, the Senate agreed to the motion to proceed, 62 to 21 (vote 258), and Senator John Thune proposed amendment S.A. 6883 for Senator Shelley Moore Capito, in the nature of a substitute. That substitute would strike the tax bill and insert BAAJA.

The original Senate bill is S. 5653, introduced September 30 by Capito, chair of the Environment and Public Works Committee, with Senators Sheldon Whitehouse, Mike Lee, and Martin Heinrich. In floor remarks released by the committee on November 9, Capito said the package includes the Ratepayer Protection Act, which she described as legislation that will make potential data centers “pay their own way instead of American consumers facing increased costs through rising utility bills.”

A final passage vote has not been held. On November 11, according to Congress.gov, cloture motions were presented on the measure and on the substitute amendment, and the Senate continued to consider the bill. White & Case, in a client alert, wrote that a final Senate vote could come the week of November 16. That timing is not confirmed on the bill's official actions list, and the path after the midterms is uncertain. Utility Dive reported on November 10 that analysts at TD Cowen cut their outlook for the bill's success from about 40 percent to around 25 percent after Democrats won both chambers, and that Jefferies analysts wrote, “Senate passage is possible, but enactment remains unlikely without a clear House strategy.”

The full-cost rule

Section 2107 of the substitute, circulated as a manager's amendment package before the November 9 vote, states a national policy: computational load owners and operators are to bear the full cost of the electric service they require and of infrastructure built to serve them, “regardless of whether they take the electric service that they request,” so that those costs are not borne by other customers, including residential customers.

To carry that out at the federal transmission level, the section directs the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, within 90 days of enactment, to revise the 1994 transmission pricing policy statement (59 Fed. Reg. 55031, Nov. 3, 1994) and to issue a notice of proposed rulemaking. The revised policy is to require public utilities and transmitting utilities to charge “eligible computational load customers” both the embedded cost of transmission service and “a reasonable assessment, as determined by the Commission, of the incremental cost.” Incremental charges are to be credited to the utility's annual transmission revenue requirement, so other customers are not billed twice for the same dollars. A final rule is due no later than one year after the notice of proposed rulemaking is issued.

The term “eligible computational load customer” is left for FERC to define by rule or order. The statutory definition of a “computational load site” itself has no megawatt floor. It covers one or more buildings or installations at a single location that primarily contain information technology infrastructure used for software applications and services; artificial intelligence training, deployment, and delivery; cryptocurrency mining; or other computational activities at a data center. Computing that is only ancillary to some other commercial or industrial purpose is excluded.

An earlier draft limited the rules to computational loads of 20 megawatts or greater. Latitude Media described that 20-megawatt cutoff in an October 29 report on the bill as it then stood. White & Case later wrote that the substitute “eliminates the threshold altogether.” The manager's package matches that description on the face of the definition: there is no 20-megawatt floor in the text. How far the transmission-pricing rewrite actually reaches will still depend on whom FERC treats as an eligible customer.

What states could require

The same section would add a new section 229 to the Federal Power Act, titled “Ratepayer protection with respect to data centers.” That provision also uses the no-threshold definition of a computational load site. It says no portion of the “retail incremental cost” of serving such a site may be recovered in other customers' rates. States may still charge computational loads more than that incremental cost and credit the surplus to other customers. A rate or contract for service to a site must be designed to recover the full retail incremental cost even if the owner or operator terminates the agreement or stops buying power before that cost has been recovered. Before a utility builds or upgrades generation, transmission, or distribution facilities to serve a site, it must require reasonable financial assurances, with credit for any assurances already given to a public utility or transmission organization for the same work.

States would also be recognized as having authority, for retail service to these loads, to run open seasons or competitive solicitations, to condition service on the customer procuring new generation sufficient to serve its demand, and to treat computational load owners and operators as a separate class that may be offered rates and interconnection priorities less favorable than those for other large industrial, manufacturing, or commercial loads.

The new federal floor would apply to computational load sites that interconnect on or after the date of enactment. Arrangements already approved by a state would remain in effect, though a state could revise them later to the extent state law allows. In other words, the substitute does not, by its own terms, reopen every existing deal on day one.

FERC and transmission organization governance

Section 2116 of the substitute would amend sections 205 and 206 of the Federal Power Act to say that, for purposes of those sections, FERC “has jurisdiction over the corporate governance of a Transmission Organization.” That is the statutory term for regional transmission organizations and independent system operators. The text does not name PJM Interconnection. White & Case described the provision as targeted at PJM. What the amendment itself does is put that governance question expressly under FERC's rate and practice authority, if the bill becomes law.

Help for local governments

Section 2117 would require the secretary of energy, within 180 days of enactment, to establish a Data Center Community Assistance Program. On request, the Energy Department would give state, local, and tribal governments technical information on the potential energy, water, infrastructure, economic, and other community impacts of a proposed computational load site, including who is expected to pay for electric upgrades and what tax abatements are on the table. The department would also publish a plain-language community toolkit and could, at a government's request, independently assess materials a developer voluntarily provides. The secretary may not recommend whether a particular site should be approved or rejected, and the section does not authorize the department to sit in on local siting decisions. Heatmap News and the National Association of Counties both flagged this program as a late addition in the manager's amendment; Heatmap noted that the text does not itself lay out a funding authorization.

Where the vote stands

Cloture on November 9 was a procedural vote to limit debate on whether to take up the vehicle, not a vote to pass BAAJA. The substitute is now the pending text, and cloture motions on that text and on the measure were filed on November 11. As of this writing, Congress.gov does not record a final Senate vote.

Support for even that first step was broad but not settled for passage. Utility Dive reported that some Democrats who voted to advance the bill, including Senator Catherine Cortez Masto of Nevada, have said they want further changes on tribal consultation and the National Historic Preservation Act, and that Cortez Masto has said she will not vote for final passage if those concerns are not addressed. Senator Jeff Merkley, who voted no, said in a statement quoted by Utility Dive that he supports the bill's transmission, clean-energy, and data-center cost-allocation provisions but objects to other features, including what he said could make it easier to build data centers powered by behind-the-meter natural gas plants.

Even a Senate pass would not make the rules law. The House would still have to act, and President Trump would have to sign the bill. Until then, the grid-cost policy, the dropped megawatt floor, and the FERC governance provision are proposals in a pending substitute, not current federal law.

The local fight is already underway

Congress is arguing about who pays for the wires. Towns have already been arguing about whether the buildings go up at all. In the November 3 midterms, voters backed limits in 46 of the 47 local measures Ballotpedia counts, as tracked on our data centers on the ballot page, with Harwood, North Dakota, the rare exception. Upcoming votes in Clarksville, Arkansas, on December 1, and Mandan, North Dakota, on December 15, are listed there as well. A federal full-cost rule, if it ever becomes law, would sit on top of that map. It would not replace it.

Related: Data center electricity rates by state (2026), where states have already written their own rules for who pays; Data Center Fights Tracker; Wilmington, Ohio: Amazon data center news.

A standalone Underclassic explainer. Daily briefing: underclassic.com. Related: data centers on the ballot. Sources: S. 5653; H.R. 2347 all actions; the manager's amendment package; Senate EPW, November 9, 2026; Senate roll call 257; White & Case; Utility Dive, November 10, 2026; Latitude Media, October 29, 2026; Heatmap News, November 7, 2026; and NACo, November 9, 2026.